Dolls, in the left corner we have Joie’s très chic Celia Poncho Sweater; in the right corner we have ModCloth’s luscious Long Flight Sweater.Though ModCloth’s magnificent creation is quite a bit thinner, and constructed out of a mix of polyester and cotton, as opposed to the cashmere of the Joie treasure; for just $42.00, in comparison to the $274.00 price tag of its couture cousin, it is every bit as capable of helping one to create that effortlessly chic style we all strive for – at a price that is oh-so alluring for the frugalista!
Your turn loves…will you be thrifty or suckered into putting on your spendthrift cap?
Fashionably yours!
Thanks to Shopbop and ModCloth for the pictures.
Don't forget to enter the Yves Saint Laurent and Apothica Love You Giveaway for your chance to win a $50.00 Gift Certificate to Apothica.
Don't forget to enter the I Dream of Baubles Giveaway for your chance to win a pair of Olivine and Padparadscha Swarovski Crystal Sterling Silver Earrings from Asquared Jewelry.
kind of digging the Mod cloth one. Isn't it great that the CA weather is letting us wear fall fashion so early! YES!
ReplyDeleteI am all over anything from Modcloth!
ReplyDeleteFab ModCloth find, darling!
ReplyDeletexoxox,
CC
I am seriously loving this and I love the Modcloth one like none other. I think sweater capes are on the list for all French Women Wannabes (aka me).
ReplyDeleteI don't think I'd mind having it thinner. Especially, if you work inside. It would be great to have at the office. I'd go for ModCloth.
ReplyDeleteThrifty for me. I like the light weight.
ReplyDeleteSuch a cool color. A very sweet poncho. ModCloth would be my choice.
ReplyDeleteModcloth is one of my favorites! Love it!
ReplyDeleteHmm, I might actually put on the spendiecap for this one. For cashmere, I would do a lot of things.
ReplyDeleteI am love with anything Modcloth!
ReplyDeleteLove it ^__^ modcloth <3 I need to get one of that in my wardrobe!
ReplyDeleteI think the cheaper one would be great to have.
ReplyDeletecool! they look very similar to me!! :)
ReplyDeletexx
Check out our fashion illustrations at Illustrated-Moodboard.com ! = )
.
i'd go for the modcloth one! great find!
ReplyDeleteI really like the ModCloth version. Hope you have a good day.
ReplyDeleteJoie all the way!
ReplyDeletewww.FashionSnag.com
I'm not a huge poncho fan, but the Joie one is stunning!
ReplyDeletei like when people wear poncho sweaters well, so either will do.
ReplyDeletehttp://ohtobeamuse.com
Loooove this poncho!
ReplyDeleteSarah.
Oooh, great finds!
ReplyDeleteƸ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ
i would be thrifty!!! at this pt in my life, i only splurge on several things and a sweater isnt one of them!
ReplyDeleteBoth of those are gorgeous! I do love cashmere, but Modcloth is wonderful as well!
ReplyDeleteGreat find! I don't mind the cheaper material... cashmere is great but soo expensive!!
ReplyDeleteVal
vals-closet.blogspot.com
For this I have to say ModCloth wins. It just looks softer.
ReplyDeletehttp://red-soledfashionista.blogspot.com/
Anything comes from ModCloth is always a big fat "yes"
ReplyDeleteI actually just got a cowl neck sweater just like this from Forever21 for $24.00! Whohoo
ReplyDeleteI might look for it in a brighter colour since my closet has too much grey and black. But I love the silhouette
ReplyDeleteFor this one I love the more expensive Joie's one, it's stunning! I love ModCloth too but the Joie's is so beautiful
ReplyDeleteg l a m o u r !!! das modell.
ReplyDeletethanks.
I think it's a great idea to get the Modcloth version and then if you wear the hell out of it take the plunge and invest in the Joie top. I love everything Joie does too.
ReplyDeleteRamblings of a Small Town Girl
Like this jumper, it is perfect for fall.
ReplyDeleteI'm liking the Joie one more (cashmere!) I'd spend $274 for it :D
ReplyDeleteAhh, my friend has THE biggest obsession with ModCloth. Maybe I should show her this shirt?
ReplyDelete(Then I could steal it from her? I'm brilliant, I know.)
QUIRKYEXPLOSION.blogspot.com
you're right but that Joie one looks so cozy and beautiful!
ReplyDeleteThe Joie one is divine=)
ReplyDeleteOh, I LOVE that Joie one so much... It looks so soft!
ReplyDeletexo Josie
http://winksmilestyle.blogspot.com
It's raining here and I am wanting that (the cheaper version) with every inch of my body.
ReplyDeleteIts Good but not soooooooooo.... I didn't like, good there must be something which should be so so...
ReplyDeleteGod I love Modclothing... I wish I could own everything in their store!
ReplyDeleteI think I would go the Joie way, both cute but again, I think Fall clothes are investments and that's a good price for a quality item for years to come!
ReplyDeleteOh, I love this poncho, very sweet! :)
ReplyDeleteI wait for you on my blog! Have a nice day!
I am always looking for sweaters in the perfect shade of greige. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI love the ModCloth one. I hope you had a wonderful weekend. Take care.
ReplyDeleteThese are both such glamorous pieces! But I don't think I can turn my back to cashmere... I'd love to be wearing it right now!!
ReplyDeleteI happen to like the ModCloth version much better, though I'm sure the Joie poncho feels luxurious!
ReplyDeleteGreat find, Erika!
ReplyDeleteAlthough I'm sure the cashmere of the Joie version is amazing, I think I like the ModCloth one better!
ReplyDeleteAah, LOVE this! It's like you read my mind:) Hope you enjoyed the weekend!
ReplyDeleteTheOwlsCloset.blogspot.com
I don't think I would rock either (my tiny frame coupled with my short stature would be swallowed up) but I bet that cashmere feels amazing. If I were to buy something like this, I feel as thought I would wear it more for outerwear anyway versus all day inside.
ReplyDeleteI love this sweater! It's adorable :)
ReplyDeleteThat GOOD GOOD Blog
Really affordable! Can't tell the difference between the two and I must admit in some of the comparisons you post, I can.
ReplyDeleteModcloth is my best choice. It looks comfortable and fresh to wear. I like also its color. Thanks and keep it up!
ReplyDeleteOhhh tough one. I always adore cashmere and this joie creation is divine, but I am also swooning over the ModCloth version!!
ReplyDelete